About Us
At just 8’ wide and 60’ long, and once an alleyway, the Mighty Fine Pizza building is now known as, “The hardest working 480 square feet in Petoskey!”
The building originated in 1966 and was Petoskey’s first pizza place. In 1993 my Dad, Bill Schmidt Sr., and I went into a father/son venture, bought the place and dedicated ourselves to producing the best quality pizza possible. Without the great example and standards my Dad set for Mighty Fine, we wouldn’t be what we are today.
Cutting no corners and using only the finest, freshest ingredients available, we’ve proudly become a Petoskey legend and have won more awards over the years than we have space for on our walls!
We set ourselves apart from the others by making our own fresh homemade dough and homemade sauce - there’s nothing ‘franchise’ about us! We buy all local, fresh products, and we chop and prep all the food right here. We also take pride in having a friendly, welcoming, neighborhood environment for both our staff and guests that make everyone enjoy their Mighty Fine experience, be it pick up or delivery.
We’re always coming up with new ideas and we really listen to what our customers have to say. Right now we’re working on a new menu that will include a healthy and lighter side – so be on the lookout for that!
Be sure to sign up for our Mighty Fine eNews to get e-mail exclusive Mighty coupons, specials and news in advance!
Drop by or call us at 231-347-3255 to place an order for pick up or fast delivery.
Thanks and Enjoy!
Bill Schmidt Jr.