cookingAt just 8’ wide and 60’ long, and once an alleyway, the Mighty Fine Pizza building is now known as, “The hardest working 480 square feet in Petoskey!”

The building originated in 1966 and was Petoskey’s first pizza place. In 1993 Bill Schmidt Sr. and Bill Schmidt Jr. went into a father/son venture, bought the place and dedicated themselves to producing the best quality pizza possible. In 2012 Mighty Fine Pizza was purchased by Earl and Ambre Flynn of Petoskey. Earl Flynn was a previous Mighty Fine Pizza employee in the early 1990’s.

Cutting no corners and using only the finest, freshest ingredients available, Mighty Fine Pizza proudly become a Petoskey legend and has won more awards over the years and the Flynn family continues to continue this tradition.

Mighty Fine Pizza is set apart from other’s in the industry because they make their own fresh homemade dough and pizza sauce. There is nothing “franchise” about Mighty Fine Pizza! You’ll find fresh and local products that are chopped and prepped by hand. Mighty Fine Pizza takes pride in having a friendly, welcoming, neighborhood environment for the staff and guests whether it is pick-up or delivery.

Be sure to like us on Facebook for updates and daily specials and deals.


    Summer Hours:  Monday thru Thursday 11am-10pm | Friday 11am-11pm | Saturday 3pm-11pm | Sunday 3pm-10pm

© 2020 Mighty Fine Pizza | 222 E. Mitchell St. Petoskey, MI 49770 | 231.347.3255 | Designbot Creative